Dissent note does not dismiss Rajan report: Shaibal GuptaStaff ReporterShare · Comment · print · TOPICS India Bihar
social issue development
Economist Shaibal Gupta, who represented Bihar as a member of the Raghuram Rajan committee, said in Patna on Sunday that the note of dissent only raised technicalities and did not dismiss the panel report.“The note of dissent was only a technical critique. If the dissenting points were incorporated, it would have been a better report, but that does not mean we are dismissing the report. We welcome the panel report which opens the door for Bihar to be entitled to maximum financial devolution. Both the report and the note have to be seen in a positive light. We were not politically driven. We worked as economists,” Mr. Gupta told a press conference in Patna.Based on the dissent note, the Opposition Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) had challenged the view that Bihar would gain from the revised framework of backwardness.The note, said Mr. Gupta, merely advised different variables, than the ones considered by the panel. For instance, the variable of per capita income should have been considered instead of monthly per capita consumption. Other variables, such as health, infant mortality, education, female literacy and per capita electricity connectivity, availability and consumption should have been taken into account.“We put our critique on record so that their cognisance is taken for course correction when future criteria are framed. The panel has said that the variable will change every five years,” he said. Special category status was not in the terms of reference of the Rajan panel. The body received a note from the Finance Ministry that the category had been subsumed.The most important contribution of the report was to devise a development index based on performance and need. In this respect Bihar stood to gain the most and could even be entitled for tax breaks, Mr. Gupta said. Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar has hailed the report as “an ideological victory,” while the BJP has criticised the document as “a lame duck report.”
Keywords: Shaibal Gupta, Rajan panel report, Nitish KumarPost Comment RELATED NEWS Rajan panel ranks Odisha most backward StateSeptember 26, 2013 'Ideological victory for Bihar'September 26, 2013 For their interests, corporates speaking in favour of one individual: Nitish KumarSeptember 27, 2013 Nitish hailing lame duck report to cosy up to Congress: BJPSeptember 27, 2013 More In: Other States | National | News You can now login with LI or FB and share your comments with othersPlease Wait while comments are loading...
1. Comments will be moderated by The Hindu editorial team.
2. Comments that are abusive, personal, incendiary or irrelevant cannot be published.
3. Please write complete sentences. Do not type comments in all capital letters,
or in all lower case letters, or using abbreviated text.
(example: u cannot substitute for you, d is not 'the', n is not 'and').
4. We may remove hyperlinks within comments.
5. Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name, to avoid rejection.
Most PopularMost CommentedEyebrows raised as Mamata is slated to inaugurate luxury mall Rahul should apologise for his remarks on ordinance: Chouhan BJP MLA’s supporters defy ban, unleash violence in Meerut village Plan to develop coastal belt on Mumbai outskirts draws flak Mumbai building crash: death toll rises to 61 Death toll climbs to 54 in Mumbai building collapse Mamata assures monetary help, jobs for Kamduni rape victim’s family Dissent note does not dismiss Rajan report: Shaibal Gupta 12 killed in fidayeen strikes in Jammu Tribunal bans digging earth for making bricks without EC
Today's Paper ePaperThis Day That AgeCrosswordArchiveObituaryGroup SitesThe Hindu?? ?????Business Line SportstarFrontlineThe Hindu CentreImagesClassifieds
The Hindu:Home |News |Opinion |Business |Sport |S & T |Features |Books |In-depth |Jobs |Classifieds |Shopping |Bus tickets |
Group Sites: The Hindu |?? ????? |Business Line |Sportstar |Frontline |The Hindu Centre |Publications |eBooks |Images |Classifieds | Comments to: firstname.lastname@example.org Copyright© 2013, The Hindu